A comparison of novels the hollow men and the great gatsby

First, he is both narrator and participant. Part of Fitzgerald's skill in The Great Gatsby shines through the way he cleverly makes Nick a focal point of the action, while simultaneously allowing him to remain sufficiently in the background. In addition, Nick has the distinct honor of being the only character who changes substantially from the story's beginning to its end. Nick, although he initially seems outside the action, slowly moves to the forefront, becoming an important vehicle for the novel's messages.

A comparison of novels the hollow men and the great gatsby

This book explores the quest for happiness and wealth through the American dream and depicts dysfunctional relationships, idealism, materialism, and corrupt values during the Jazz Age.

The Great Gatsby is a rags to riches story of a man in pursuit of his dreams. In The Great Gatsby there are several men that have a physical dominance over women. Daisy selfishly seeks her own freedoms away from life of motherhood.

Independent thought and free will do not exist for Daisy because the only role she is required to play is that of a mother, a wife, and an image for men to lust after. Daisy is a lot like Gatsby in the sense that they are both dreamers.

Daisy clings to the hope that one day her dreams will come true just like Gatsby holds tightly to the hope one day he will be with Daisy again. However, when Gatsby challenges Daisy to break free, ruin her life and submit to Gatsby instead, she returns to submission with Tom.

Both choices given to Daisy are ones that require her to submit to a male figure rather than follow her own heart. Women are just silly dreamers, incapable of intelligent thoughts and realistic goals. Men are the ones that achieve success and status. For Gatsby to also be comparatively feminine, just proves that Fitzgerald views women as incapable of achieving true success.

Jordan is another woman portrayed as having inacceptable behavior through her promiscuity. Jordan has had sex before marriage and is portrayed as a manipulative and selfish liar. Jordan is also depicted as incapable of having legitimate success because her career as a professional golfer was built off cheating at tournaments.

Is Fitzgerald implying that she would be incapable of being successful without cheating? Just like Daisy is a fraud by her exterior image and extramarital affairs with Gatsby, Jordan is a fraud out of her unwillingness to submit to a masculine figure through her means of success.

However, because she really is a woman, she must have cheated her way to the top because there is no way she could share equal success with men as a female. Myrtle is also depicted as a fraud. Myrtle is clearly being oppressed by men in this book through the physical, mental, and emotional abuse she endures.

Her life is incomplete without a man in charge of it. Since she is no longer happy with her husband, she turns to Tom to give her life new meaning and excitement. Myrtle is described as being older and unattractive and, according to Nick, obnoxious and loud.

Myrtle is the only woman depicted as having some control over her life through her controlling relationships yet her appearances indicate worthlessness. Myrtle represents another selfish woman because of the pressure she puts on Tom to divorce Daisy and the deliberate public adulterous affair she has with Tom.

Gatsby is killed by

These three women are portrayed in a very negative light, and although this negativity leads readers to disliking them, all three of these women are served an injustice.

Daisy is once again held captive by patriarchy through a lonely loveless life after Gatsby dies and she returns to Tom. Her fate is left to the hands and mercy of an unfaithful husband, Tom, and the duties of motherhood. Myrtle, the most sexually aggressive woman in this text, persistently challenges patriarchy with her confidence in seducing men and boldness to pursue her desires.

Myrtle is ridiculed for implying that she is above her husband and physically harmed for her boldness when Tom hits her in the face and she is killed in a car accident. In both of these instances Myrtle challenges male authority in her life and is repaid with abuse.

Women are oppressed in this text for attempting to break out of a patriarchal mold and be assertive.

A comparison of novels the hollow men and the great gatsby

The Great Gatsby displays the unjust power relationships among men and women as glamorous. Nick is just as guilty as Tom in his mistreatment of women for supporting his patriarchal values by not standing up for the women being mistreated.

All of the characters in this text are complex characters but the only voice we ever hear is Nick, a male narrator, who is drawn to feminine men. The narrator is already anti-feminist in his attraction to male characters with a few feminine qualities, how are the women in this text supposed to be justly represented if they are being scrutinized by a narrator who clearly sees no value in them?

The only details we get about Jordan from Nick are the ones showing she is similar to men. In The Great Gatsby, men take advantage of the women they romanticize.

Gatsby spends his entire life seeking acceptance of his relationship with Daisy but never validates her as a person. Daisy is merely an object to him, a goal. Gatsby desperately reaches to obtain Daisy, not just her affection but her as a possession. The revealed consequences of trying to break free from male dominated morals reaffirm that women who seek to shatter traditional social structures tread on dangerous waters.

Kerr wrote in his piece about being feminine in The Great Gatsby and how femininity equates to a weakness. Fitzgerald continues to describe the women in a negative light and includes Myrtle in this by portraying her as an arrogant woman whose voice is one of the loudest in the room.TITLE: Adaptation and Originality in The Great Gatsby AUTHOR: Simon C.J.

Jamieson, B •. A. (Cambridge University) considered to be his finest novel, the product of an undeniable 'The Hollow Men' upon Conrad's 'Heart of Darkness'" he traced. Authors and Texts. Read about writers from around the world with an A-to-Z listings, profiles, biographies and more.

Also find summaries and analysis of famous poems, novels. Take a journey into the past and reminisce about great moments in Philadelphia history.

Parallels Between "The Hollow Men" and the Great Gatsby Essay “The Hollow Men” by T - Parallels Between "The Hollow Men" and the Great Gatsby Essay introduction.

A comparison of novels the hollow men and the great gatsby

S. Eliot and The Great Gatsby by Scott Fitzgerald but have similar themes and were both published in In marked contrast to “The Great Gatsby”, the values and attitudes on display in “The Plough and the Stars” and “Children of Men” are often shaped in response to the violent uprisings and depressed social settings that feature in both texts.

The Great Gatsby is a novel, F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic social critique, in which the American dream of Rags to Riches is exposed as a noble illusion and self-absorbed, emotionally bankrupt Rich Bitches are the reality. Largely because of this frank but wistful consideration of idealism vs.

human nature, it has come to be considered the.

Gatsby and The Hollowmen by Tyler Collins on Prezi